You filed a roof insurance claim after storm damage — only to receive that dreaded letter:
“Your claim has been denied.”
If this sounds familiar, you’re not alone. Many Georgia homeowners face insurance denials after hail, wind, or storm events, often for reasons that can be challenged successfully.
The good news? A denied claim isn’t the end of the story. With the right evidence, strategy, and professional support, you can often reopen, appeal, or supplement your roof insurance claim — and get the coverage you deserve.
In this complete guide, we’ll explain why claims get denied, how to respond, and what to do next to turn that “no” into a “yes.”
Why Roof Insurance Claims Get Denied in Georgia
Insurance companies are businesses — and sometimes, their goal is to minimize payouts. Understanding why your claim was denied is the first step in reversing it.
- “Normal Wear and Tear”
If your roof is over 15–20 years old, insurers may claim the damage was due to age or neglect rather than a storm. This is one of the most common reasons for denial.
What to do: Get a second inspection from a licensed roofing contractor who can document storm-specific impact (hail bruising, wind creases, etc.) with date-stamped photos.
- “No Storm Damage Found”
Sometimes adjusters misjudge or miss the extent of the damage — especially if they inspect from the ground or during bright daylight when bruising is hard to see.
What to do: Request a re-inspection and provide evidence from a roofing expert. At Roofers & Contractors, we use drones, hail maps, and infrared scans to prove impact damage.
- “Pre-Existing Damage”
If the insurer claims your roof was damaged before the storm, they’ll deny coverage.
What to do: Use NOAA hail data and Google Earth historical imagery to show when the damage occurred relative to the storm date. A contractor-adjuster team can handle this documentation.
- “Late Filing”
In Georgia, you typically have one year from the storm date to file a claim. If you file late, insurers may reject it automatically.
What to do: File as soon as possible. If you’re within the one-year window but were delayed for legitimate reasons (like hidden leaks), a professional appeal can reopen the claim.
- “Cosmetic Damage Only”
Insurance may say the hail marks are “cosmetic,” meaning they don’t affect function. But even minor granule loss can shorten shingle life and cause leaks later.
What to do: Get a roofing report showing how the “cosmetic” damage has compromised the roof’s performance.
- “Policy Exclusions or High Deductible”
Sometimes a denial isn’t about the damage — it’s about fine print. Many policies have wind or hail deductibles that are higher than standard deductibles.
What to do: Review your policy’s “Exclusions” and “Deductibles” sections. A contractor-adjuster can help you interpret them and estimate actual repair costs.
Steps to Take Immediately After an Insurance Claim Denial
When your insurance claim is denied, time is critical. Here’s what to do next.
Step 1: Don’t Panic — Review the Denial Letter Carefully
Your denial letter should explain:
- The official reason for denial
- The policy sections cited
- How to appeal or request a re-inspection
Highlight keywords like “wear and tear,” “maintenance,” “no storm damage,” or “late submission.” This helps you plan your next move.
Step 2: Schedule a Free Independent Roof Inspection
Before appealing, get an unbiased assessment from a licensed roofing contractor (not affiliated with your insurer).
At Roofers & Contractors, we inspect for:
- Hail, wind, and debris impact
- Roof age and wear patterns
- Shingle creasing, granule loss, or flashing damage
- NOAA storm verification for your address
We then produce a detailed report that you can submit as part of your appeal.
Step 3: Gather Evidence
The more proof you have, the stronger your case. Gather:
- Date-stamped roof photos
- Contractor inspection report
- Hail or wind data from your storm date
- Any quotes or estimates from local roofers
- Communication records with your insurer
Keep all evidence organized in one file — you’ll need it for your supplemental claim or appeal.
Step 4: Request a Re-Inspection or File an Appeal
If you believe the denial was wrong, contact your insurer and formally request a re-inspection.
Georgia insurance law allows you to submit additional documentation or request a new adjuster if the first inspection was incomplete.
You can also file an appeal through your insurer’s internal review process, referencing your new inspection report and photos.
Step 5: Get a Licensed Adjuster on Your Side
Here’s where most homeowners go wrong — they fight the insurance company alone.
At Roofers & Contractors, we’re not just roofers; we’re licensed insurance adjusters. That means we understand:
- Policy language and fine print
- Claim documentation standards
- Supplemental filing processes
- How to negotiate directly with your insurance carrier
With our help, homeowners across North Atlanta, Cumming, and Alpharetta have overturned denied claims worth thousands.
Step 6: Consider a Public Adjuster or Legal Review
If the insurer still refuses coverage, a public adjuster or attorney can step in.
- Public Adjuster: Represents you (not the insurer) to negotiate a fair settlement.
- Attorney: Recommended for large-scale disputes or bad-faith claim handling.
However, most homeowners don’t need to escalate this far when they have a qualified contractor-adjuster team handling evidence and communication.
How Roof Claim Appeals Work in Georgia
The insurance appeal process can seem intimidating, but it’s straightforward when handled systematically.
- Submit a Written Appeal – Reference your denial letter, policy number, and new evidence.
- Attach Supporting Documents – Include your contractor’s report, hail maps, and storm photos.
- Request a Second Adjuster Visit – Ask for a new adjuster or engineer for re-evaluation.
- Wait for Response – Insurers typically respond within 10–30 business days.
- Negotiate if Needed – Provide cost comparisons and repair estimates to prove reasonable market value.
Tip: If you’ve already replaced your roof out of pocket, you can still file a supplemental claim to recover expenses — as long as you have receipts and evidence.
When You Can Reopen a Closed Claim
Even if your claim was denied months ago, you may still be able to reopen it if:
- New evidence or inspection findings emerge
- The original adjuster missed obvious damage
- There’s proof of bad-faith handling or error
- The storm event has verified data for your area
Georgia homeowners typically have 12 months from the original storm date to reopen or supplement a claim.
At Roofers & Contractors, we help homeowners file these supplemental claims with complete documentation and insurance-ready reports.
Common Mistakes Homeowners Make After a Denied Claim
- Accepting the denial without question.
Adjusters make mistakes. Always get a second opinion. - Delaying action.
The longer you wait, the harder it becomes to link damage to a specific storm event. - Hiring unlicensed roofers.
Unverified contractors can invalidate claims or cause code issues. - Paying out of pocket too soon.
Repairs without insurer approval can forfeit reimbursement. - Ignoring small leaks.
Even minor water intrusion can lead to attic mold and rot — and insurers may later blame “neglect.”
How Roofers & Contractors Helps Reverse Denied Claims
At Roofers & Contractors, we specialize in helping Georgia homeowners overturn insurance denials and secure proper coverage for roof replacement.
Here’s how we do it:
- Free, no-obligation re-inspection within 24–48 hours
- Detailed storm verification reports using NOAA data
- Licensed adjusters on staff to communicate directly with your insurer
- Claim appeal assistance with complete documentation
- Turnkey roof replacement once your claim is approved
We’ve helped hundreds of homeowners in Cumming, Alpharetta, Johns Creek, and Gwinnett County get new roofs approved — even after initial denials.
Related Pages:
Preventing Future Denials — Proactive Roof Maintenance Tips
- Schedule annual inspections.
Regular maintenance proves you’ve cared for your roof — helpful for future claims. - Document all repairs.
Keep receipts, photos, and contractor info. - After each storm, inspect for debris or missing shingles.
Quick response = stronger evidence if you need to file a claim. - Review your insurance policy yearly.
Understand deductibles, exclusions, and coverage type (ACV vs RCV). - Work with local roofing professionals.
Local contractors understand Georgia’s storm trends and insurer expectations.
FAQs About Denied Roof Insurance Claims in Georgia
Q1: Can I appeal a denied roof claim in Georgia?
Yes. Georgia homeowners have the right to appeal and submit new evidence for reconsideration.
Q2: How long do I have to appeal?
Usually within 12 months of the storm date or initial denial. Always check your policy for exact deadlines.
Q3: Will appealing hurt my insurance rates?
No — appealing a denial doesn’t affect your premiums. Only approved claims may influence rates.
Q4: What if my insurance says it’s “cosmetic damage”?
If the hail damage affects shingle performance or lifespan, it can still qualify for coverage with proper documentation.
Q5: Do I need a lawyer to overturn a denial?
Not usually. Licensed roofing contractors and adjusters can resolve most disputes without legal action.
Having your roof insurance claim denied can be discouraging — but it’s not the end. With proper inspection, documentation, and advocacy, many denied claims in Georgia get reversed.
Don’t accept the first “no.” Let Roofers & Contractors handle your inspection, re-inspection, and appeal process. We’ll work directly with your insurer to secure the coverage you deserve and replace your roof quickly and professionally.
Call today or schedule a free re-inspection online to reopen your denied claim and get your roof back to full protection.